And Now For Our Second Feature
Review by Emily Trosprel
9th Grade BHHS Senior Entertainment Editor
Lady in the Water
M. Night Shyamalan has a lot riding on the outcome of “Lady in the Water”. He reportedly left Disney (who had produced his previous four films) in a huff after they expressed their dislike of the script, and Shyamalan brought it to Warner Brothers. Now, Disney will be waiting to see if they were right in passing on the film, and Warner Brothers will be waiting to see if they were right in scooping it up. Unfortunately for Shyamalan, a genre that is hard to define coupled with some of the most misleading trailers of the year make box office prospects grim. Fortunately for him however, the movie he has made is a magical tale that will invoke strong feelings (whether good or bad) in all who see it. The plot focuses on apartment building superintendent Cleveland Heep (Paul Giamatti) who late one night tries to catch what he thinks are troublemakers swimming in the pool after hours. Instead he finds a “Narf” (a sort of sea nymph here played by Bryce Dallas Howard) named Story who is trying to return to her world. Cleveland must work with his tenants to help her and protect her from the creatures that would stop her from ever leaving.
There have been two common complaints against “Lady in the Water”. Number one is that it isn’t scary enough or isn’t enough like a horror movie. Blame bad advertising on the confusion, but this is not a horror movie—the best genre to describe it would be fantasy. The second complaint has been against M. Night Shyamalan for casting himself in a meaty role. Let’s be honest, there won’t be any Oscars coming Shyamalan’s way in the near future, but that’s not to say the performance wasn’t a good one. He’s a better actor then some give him credit for. So now that we’ve targeted the complaints, let’s focus on the good points. One of those is that Paul Giamatti can act to put it simply. While Bryce and the rest of the cast are solid, it’s Giamatti who steals the show, and it’s hard to imagine the movie without him (Kevin Costner was actually considered for the role—now there’s a scary thought). Now, you may go the theater to see “Lady in the Water” and hate it. Many will—the film’s very nature makes it inevitable. However if you’re part of the crowd who falls on the other side of the fence, know that you are in for a beautifully crafted, imaginative, and intelligent treat that will stay with you for a very long time. Three out of four stars for Lady In The Water.